Curious about the contrast between a basket setting and a prong setting?
Look no further. In this informative Twirl Weddings guide, I’ll address the key inquiries regarding these two types of settings:
- Does a prong setting provide superior protection for a diamond?
- Which setting tends to be more costly?
- Do 8 prongs outperform 4 prongs?
Differences Between Basket Setting and Prong Setting
The main disparities between a basket setting and a prong setting are as follows:
- Basket settings incorporate prongs that are part of a basket connected to the ring’s shank, while prong settings typically feature prongs that extend from the metal band to the center stone.
- Cleaning basket settings can be more challenging compared to prong settings, which are relatively easier to clean.
- Basket settings often come at a higher cost due to their utilization of more metal, whereas prong settings require less metal and are therefore less expensive.
- A basket setting falls under the category of prong settings, but prong settings encompass a wider range of variations.
Confusion Surrounding Engagement Ring Settings
When it comes to engagement ring settings, we often have a limited understanding. We are familiar with the most popular settings, such as solitaire, halo, and bezel settings, which have gained recognition over the years.
However, these settings only represent a small portion of the available engagement ring styles, focusing primarily on how the center stone is placed.
It is important to note that the choice of engagement ring setting is not solely determined by the center stone. For instance, a flush setting style refers to an engagement ring where the center stone sits flush with the shank. This style can encompass bezel settings, halo settings, or tension settings. The key requirement for a flush setting is that the ring head aligns smoothly with the band.
Today, we will compare the basket setting with the prong setting to assist you in narrowing down your options and finding an ideal ring.
Appearance – Basket Setting vs Prong Setting
Prong and basket settings have some notable similarities, but they also differ in certain aspects. Let’s delve into the visual comparison of these ring styles.
Basket Setting
A basket setting is where the center stone of an engagement ring is supported by horizontal metal bands that resemble a basket. Some basket settings are simple in design, while others feature intricate vintage details.
Interestingly, basket settings can fall under other well-known ring settings too. For example, if a cathedral setting incorporates a basket, it becomes a basket setting as well. Most cathedral ring settings cannot be classified as flush settings because their profiles tend to be relatively high.
RECOMMENDED: Engagement Ring Cathedral Settings
In fact, our cathedral basket setting is actually a type of prong setting. Yes, that’s right! Any ring setting that includes a basket underneath is also considered a basket setting.
Prong Setting
Similarly, halo settings are not categorized as prong settings, even though they have small prongs. Traditional prong settings have prongs that extend over the stone, originating from the ring’s band. Halo ring settings do not follow this pattern. Prong settings can be either high or low settings.
There are various types of prong settings available, with the iconic Tiffany setting being the most popular one. This setting, famously introduced by Tiffany and Co., is characterized by its low height and six prongs that securely hold the stone in a distinct “Tiffany” manner. However, it is more appropriate to refer to this prong setting as a “Tiffany-style” setting, as the name “Tiffany” is copyrighted and associated with a specific brand and ring design.
RECOMMENDED: Tiffany Setting vs. Prong Setting: What is the Difference?
Let’s break down the appearance of a prong setting into different prong styles. There are claw prongs, flat-tab prongs, button prongs, round prongs, and V-shaped prongs.
AVAILABLE ON BRILLIANTEARTH
A significant advantage of a standard prong diamond ring compared to a basket diamond ring lies in its exceptional light performance, often referred to as the sparkle of the diamond. A standard prong setting with four prongs allows more light to enter the diamond compared to a six or eight prong setting.
The design of prong settings offers a clear view of the diamond’s brilliance from all angles. Even between the prongs, there is enough space for ample light to reflect and refract out of the diamond. On the other hand, in a basket ring, a significant portion of the diamond’s bottom is obstructed by objects like the basket or metal details. This can affect the sparkle of round diamonds, although it provides better protection for the diamond’s culet. However, basket rings still have their own sparkle, so don’t let that discourage you.
Durability – Basket Setting vs Prong Setting
Both setting styles are perfect for an engagement ring that you plan to wear for many years. However, there are some specific details you should know about each one.
Basket Setting
In most basket settings, the prongs are short. This allows the center stone to be securely held by the prongs, almost sitting within the basket. Short prongs have their advantages as they don’t extend too far over the surface of the stone, reducing the chances of catching on fabrics.
RECOMMENDED: Sterling Silver vs Gold
When selecting wedding bands for a basket setting, it’s important to be cautious. Basket settings often have a substantial amount of metal. If your engagement ring and wedding band are not soldered together, they may rub against each other, causing wear on the metal band.
AVAILABLE ON JAMESALLEN
You should also be mindful of any impacts or knocks. If you lead an active lifestyle, it might be a good idea to keep your basket setting safely stored away during those activities. Short prongs offer less flexibility, making it unlikely for the center stone to become loose, but it’s better to be safe than sorry.
Prong Setting
A prong engagement ring is often considered more suitable for individuals with active lifestyles. However, if you’re seeking maximum security, a bezel setting, which has no prongs at all, is worth considering. Nonetheless, prong settings can still be a good option for those with busy lives.
For added security, you can opt for double prongs, such as double claw prongs, especially for larger stones. A six or eight prong engagement ring provides an extra layer of protection. However, keep in mind that having too many prongs can affect the diamond’s sparkle, so finding the right balance is essential.
RECOMMENDED: Claw Prongs vs Round Prongs
Cost – Basket Setting vs Prong Setting
Determining the cost comparison between a basket and prong setting can be quite challenging. The price of an engagement ring is typically influenced by the center stone and the karat gold used. Several factors contribute to the overall cost, but the main factors are related to the diamond itself and the number of small diamonds in the ring setting. Generally, more diamonds lead to a higher price tag.
If I had to make an informed guess, a basket setting would likely be more expensive than a traditional prong setting. Some prong-set engagement rings can be quite intricate and use a significant amount of precious metal. However, most of them have 4, 6, or 8 prongs that extend from horizontal bands, utilizing minimal metal.
RECOMMENDED: Best Place to Buy Conflict Free Diamonds
In contrast, a basket setting is more intricate and requires more precious metal compared to a standard prong setting. Even if it has 6 or 8 prongs, they are usually slender in design.
Basket settings are often adorned with accent stones encrusted around the basket, which can drive up the cost. However, it’s important to note that not all basket settings will necessarily be more expensive. There can be variations in pricing depending on different factors.
To provide you with an idea of the price range and complexity, here are two examples of basket-style and traditional prong-style ring settings. Please keep in mind that these prices are for the settings only and do not include a center gemstone. Prices are subject to change.
Pavé Knife Edge Lotus Basket Engagement Ring
AVAILABLE ON JAMESALLEN
Split Prong Engagement Ring
AVAILABLE ON JAMESALLEN
Conclusion
Ultimately, the decision of whether to go with a basket setting or a prong setting boils down to your personal taste and preferences.
When it comes to crafting your dream ring, there are many engagement ring settings and styles to explore. Each style comes with its own advantages and disadvantages. It’s important to assess whether they align with your preferences and lifestyle. So go ahead and embark on your joyful search for the perfect ring!
