Curious about the dissimilarity of a Tiffany setting and a prong setting? Look no further!
In this handy Twirl Weddings guide, I’ll provide you with answers to commonly asked questions regarding these two types of ring settings, such as:
- How does a Tiffany-style setting differ from a Tiffany setting?
- What makes Tiffany settings pricier?
- Are 4 prong settings inferior to 6 prong settings?
Differences between Tiffany Setting vs Prong Setting
- A Tiffany setting is a unique ring design exclusively created by Tiffany & Co., while a prong setting is a common style of ring setting available in the general market.
- The cost of a branded Tiffany prong setting tends to be higher, while an unbranded prong setting with a “Tiffany-style” can be more affordable.
- If you’re looking to purchase a genuine Tiffany Setting, you can only do so through Tiffany’s or their authorized partners. On the other hand, prong settings, including those with a “Tiffany-style,” can be found in various places and jewelry stores.
The Different Types of Engagement Ring Settings
Purchasing diamonds can be quite intricate, and the same applies to buying the setting for an engagement ring. On the surface, it may not appear complicated. Many of us are familiar with terms like solitaire engagement ring and halo setting. While the bezel setting was once less popular, it is gaining recognition and becoming the preferred choice for those leading active lifestyles.
All these ring settings can be categorized and further diversified. Some setting names describe how the center diamond is placed, such as solitaire or halo settings. Other types of settings are named based on the metalwork beneath the main stone, like basket or cathedral settings.
RECOMMENDED: Basket Setting vs Prong Setting
Among all the available ring options, the prong setting is the most widely favored for engagement rings. Prong settings encompass various styles as they are essential for securely holding the diamond in place.
In the realm of jewelry, you often come across the term “Tiffany setting” for engagement rings. Tiffany & Co. stands as one of the oldest and most renowned designer brands. Today, we will be comparing the popular Tiffany setting with the traditional prong setting.
Appearance – Tiffany Setting vs Prong Setting
Tiffany setting rings and prong setting rings may appear quite similar at first glance, making it challenging to distinguish between them. Let’s explore the reasons behind this.
Tiffany Settings
The Tiffany setting ring can be categorized into two types of settings. An authentic Tiffany setting ring is a designer ring setting exclusively crafted by Tiffany & Co. Many of you might be familiar with this renowned brand, especially if you’re a fan of Audrey Hepburn in the classic 1961 film, Breakfast at Tiffany’s.
The introduction of the Tiffany Setting dates back to 1886 when Charles Lewis Tiffany, the founder of the company, made it publicly available. Tiffany & Co. was already renowned for their exquisite diamonds, and the introduction of this ring setting added to their reputation.
The classic Tiffany setting features a simple yet ingenious design. The diamond is elevated and held securely in place by six prongs. Tiffany’s has since created other iconic setting styles, such as their Tiffany bezel setting.
The Tiffany Ring setting is highly regarded worldwide, not only because of the prestigious brand name, but also due to its exceptional quality and ability to keep the diamond secure, even for those leading active lifestyles.
While there are alternative brands that offer ring styles resembling the Tiffany setting, they cannot replicate the same engineering due to copyright restrictions. Nevertheless, these alternatives still provide secure options for high-quality ring settings.
Prong Settings
When you hold a Tiffany diamond ring next to a prong-set ring, they might appear almost identical. That’s because both a Tiffany setting and a Tiffany-style setting belong to the prong setting family.
AVAILABLE ON BRILLIANTEARTH
The phrase “prong setting” refers to a group that includes a majority of ring styles since most settings require prongs. The patented Tiffany setting falls under the prong setting category. If it features long prongs that firmly hold the diamond, it is typically considered a prong setting. Various popular ring styles can be categorized as prong settings. A prong setting may have a resemblance to a classic Tiffany setting or exhibit a completely different look.
RECOMMENDED: Engagement Ring Cathedral Settings
Durability – Tiffany Setting vs Prong Setting
Both types of ring settings are suitable for long-lasting engagement rings. However, there are specific details you should be aware of for each setting.
Tiffany Setting
The classic Tiffany setting is renowned for its patented and well-engineered design, making it one of the most durable ring settings for engagement rings. The prongs rise from the band and securely hold the diamond in place. On the other hand, a Tiffany-style setting lacks the same engineered design, resulting in a potentially lower level of durability compared to an authentic Tiffany setting.
However, it’s important to consider the number of prongs in a setting. More prongs can sometimes become inconvenient as they have a higher chance of catching on fabrics. Conversely, fewer prongs allow more light to enter the diamond, enhancing its brilliance. This aspect may be particularly important for fancy-shaped diamonds, as a well-cut round diamond tends to perform exceptionally well in terms of light reflection.
Prong Setting
A prong setting can encounter similar issues as a Tiffany setting when it comes to snagging on fabrics. However, unlike the Tiffany setting, a prong setting does not have a fixed number of prongs, so you won’t face any concerns regarding the impact on light return.
Since prong settings come in various styles, it’s impossible to list all the pros and cons of each one. Different types of prongs, such as claw prongs, offer varying levels of security by firmly grasping the diamond. Double claw prongs provide even more stability, although it may not always be necessary.
RECOMMENDED: Claw Prongs vs. Round Prongs
If you notice your prongs catching on fabrics, it’s advisable to inspect your ring. Prongs can sometimes catch, but it could also be a sign that they need to be retipped.
Retipping prongs is a regular maintenance task required for all rings. If your ring does not come with a lifetime warranty, you’ll have to bear the cost yourself. However, not getting it done could potentially lead to the loss of the entire diamond, which is a far worse outcome, wouldn’t you agree?
Moreover, if you purchase your prong setting from a retailer like James Allen, you can have this service covered for life and free of charge. This coverage extends to smaller stones in the setting as well.
Occasionally, prong settings can suffer damage if subjected to a strong impact. Some individuals have experienced their 6-prong setting ring getting hit and the entire head of the ring, along with the prongs, coming off. This could be an unfortunate accident due to the use of softer metals or a craftsmanship issue.
This also highlights the distinction between an authentic Tiffany setting and a Tiffany-styled setting. If you wish to minimize the chances of such incidents, you may consider opting for a stronger metal, such as platinum, instead of gold.
Cost – Tiffany Engagement Ring Setting vs Prong Engagement Ring Setting
If you have your heart set on an authentic Tiffany & Co. ring, be prepared to open your wallet wide. Tiffany & Co. is one of the largest and most renowned designer jewelry brands, if not the largest. When it comes to designer rings, you’re paying for the brand name. This holds true for other brands like Harry Winston, Neil Lane, and Vera Wang as well.
So, just how expensive can a ring setting from Tiffany be? Let’s compare. A traditional Tiffany engagement ring setting with six prongs and a platinum band costs a whopping $14,000.
Now, let’s consider a similar six-prong setting ring. The setting alone costs $1,040 for white gold and $1,240 for platinum. If you add a center stone, such as a 1.01 carat cushion diamond with I color, VS2 clarity, and an excellent cut, the total cost for a six-prong engagement ring from James Allen would be around $5,800.
AVAILABLE ON JAMESALLEN
Clearly, these two rings are not exactly the same, but is there an $8,000 difference? Most likely not.
When it comes to prong setting rings, the price can vary a lot. A simple prong setting usually costs less than $500 if you buy it online. But if you want a fancier design, like a cathedral setting or a basket prong setting, you might end up paying $800 or more. The total cost depends on how complicated the design is and whether you choose gold or platinum. Platinum rings are generally around $200 more expensive than gold ones.
RECOMMENDED: 10K vs. 14K vs. 18K vs. 24K Gold
Final Thoughts – Tiffany Setting vs Prong Setting
When someone desires a Tiffany diamond ring, they are thinking of the brand rather than the specific style. Tiffany settings fall under the broader category of prong settings.
The classic Tiffany ring has a design that is both patented and copyrighted, making it unique to the Tiffany brand. No other company can replicate this design. These rings are known for their exceptional durability but come with a hefty price tag.
On the other hand, a prong setting is a general term encompassing various styles of engagement rings that feature prongs. There are different types of prongs and prong settings available. Some rings resemble the look of a 6-prong setting similar to Tiffany’s, but they are more affordable.
Both types of rings would be wonderful choices, so it’s important to consider what suits you and your circumstances best.
