Claw Prongs vs Round Prongs – Which is More Secure?

Claw Prongs vs Round Prongs – Which is More Secure?

Are you curious about the contrast between claw prongs and round prongs?

Look no further. In this handy Twirl Weddings guide, I will address the key inquiries regarding these two types of prongs:

  • Are round prongs suitable for princess cut diamonds?
  • Do claw prongs offer enhanced safety?
  • Which prong type is considered the finest?

Exploring the Differences Between Claw Prongs and Round Prongs

  • Claw prongs possess a pointed shape, while round prongs are flat and circular.
  • Claw prongs offer the option of double prongs, whereas round prongs consist of single prongs.
  • Round prongs are associated with a minimalist aesthetic, while claw prongs are known for their edgier appearance.
  • Round prongs allow for a greater visibility of the diamond, while most claw prongs cover more of the diamond.

Understanding the Purpose of Prongs

The primary role of prongs in an engagement ring or any other type of ring is to securely hold the stones in place. Prongs can be crafted from various malleable metals, although precious metals are commonly used. At jewelry stores, prong settings are typically made of gold, platinum, or sterling silver.

RECOMMENDED: Platinum vs. White Gold

Prong settings represent the traditional style of an engagement ring setting. Some ring settings emphasize the design of the band, while others focus on the centerpiece of the ring. For instance, the cathedral setting and the Tiffany setting are popular prong settings. You may have even heard of a cathedral solitaire engagement ring.

Prong Setting

Prong settings encompass any ring setting that necessitates the use of prongs to secure the center stone. However, there are different styles of prongs to choose from. Today, we’ll compare claw prongs and round prongs.

Appearance – Claw Prongs and Round Prongs

Engagement rings available in stores commonly feature four prongs encircling the center stone. However, some rings also offer six or eight prong settings.

Claw Prongs

Claw prongs present a distinctive visual appeal for your engagement ring. These metal prongs emerge from beneath the central diamond and curve over its edges, resembling talons meticulously crafted from precious materials like gold or platinum.

Engagement Ring with Claw Prong Setting


Many individuals are captivated by the distinctive style of claw prongs. Unlike prongs of uniform width, they taper towards the ends, resembling claws. While the term “claws” might not sound delicate, it adds a touch of charm that many find irresistible.

RECOMMENDED:  Yellow Gold vs White Gold

Some people are so enamored by the allure of claw prongs that they desire even more of them. Double claw prongs have gained popularity among enthusiasts of this style.

On the other hand, some individuals are not fond of how claw prongs extend over the diamond. They argue that claw prongs limit the entry of light into the diamond, especially when opting for a six or eight prong ring design.

In such cases, petite claw prongs might be preferable. These are smaller versions of the claw prong appearance, providing less coverage of the diamond’s surface while still ensuring its security.

Round Prongs

Round prongs may not be the most exciting choice for a diamond engagement ring. Nevertheless, there is a reason why most rings feature them—they are popular and equally timeless.

When comparing an engagement ring with claw prongs to one with round prongs, the latter offers a timeless and classic style. While individuals may appreciate the unique appearance of prongs when they’re younger, their preference might change as they age. Round prongs eliminate such concerns.

Engagement Ring with Round Prong Setting


Round prongs emerge from the lower part of the central diamond and snugly embrace the edges of the diamond ring. Although they don’t extend over the diamond’s girdle, they provide a secure hold. The upper part of round prongs features smooth edges. These rounded prongs are highly versatile and can complement various diamond shapes.

Round Prong Diamond Stud Earrings


However, for diamonds with sharp edges like princess cuts, marquise cuts, or heart-shaped diamonds, many people prefer V-shaped prongs. V prongs are designed to delicately wrap around the pointed edges of these diamond shapes, offering a better fit compared to rounded edges.

RECOMMENDED: Princess Cut Diamond Shape

Round prongs are best suited for diamond shapes that possess smoother edges, which is why they are commonly found on diamonds with a round or cushion cut.

Durability – Claw Prongs and Round Prongs

Both claw prongs and round prongs effectively secure your diamond in place. However, they share similar vulnerabilities, such as wear and the need for retipping. Both types of prongs can also potentially snag and break off from the engagement ring.

Claw Prong

In a claw prong setting, the prongs extend over the diamond’s top half, known as the crown. If you opt for double prongs, you’ll have a total of eight prongs securely holding onto the crown.

Due to their extended coverage, claw prongs are considered more durable than rounded prongs.

On the other hand, the pointed edges of claw prongs are more prone to catching on fabrics. If the prongs catch too frequently, they can be pulled off the diamond, resulting in a loose setting.


Round Prong

A round prong ring provides the same level of security for your diamond as any other prong style. However, they do not extend as far over the diamond as claw prongs do. As a result, more light can enter the diamond in your engagement ring, enhancing its sparkle compared to a claw prong setting.

Both prong styles will effectively protect the center stone in your engagement ring. Nevertheless, claw prongs offer slightly more protection, especially when using double prongs.

Similar to flat tab prongs, round prongs do not catch as easily as claw prongs. However, after prolonged wear, they may still wear down and require retipping.

Cost – Claw Prongs and Round Prongs

The price variation between a claw prong setting and round prongs is not significantly different. Determining an exact cost is challenging as ring settings are priced based on factors like the amount of gold used, complexity of design, karat of gold, and other considerations.

However, to provide you with a general idea, let’s take a look at two rings from our partners at James Allen featuring claw and round styles:

  • Claw Prong Solitaire Engagement Ring (Flush Fit) in 14K White Gold


  • Diamond Pavé Basket Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold



The reality is, there isn’t a flawless choice of prongs for the perfect ring. An engagement ring is crafted from delicate precious metals and worn over the years, which means it will require maintenance at some point.

Both claw and round styles of prongs on an engagement ring offer durability. The main distinction between these two styles lies in their aesthetic appeal and personal preference.

If you’re interested in either round prongs or claw prongs, I suggest exploring the selection at James Allen. They provide options for both single claw prongs and even double prongs.

I hope this guide has given you a clear understanding of the difference between round prongs and claw prongs. Enjoy your search for the ideal ring!

Leave a Reply