Fancy Orange Diamonds and Where to Buy Them

Fancy Orange Diamonds and Where to Buy Them

Are you interested in those special orange diamonds that look really fancy? Well, you’ve come to the perfect spot!

In this helpful Twirl Weddings guide, I’ll provide answers to the most common queries about orange diamonds. Moreover, I’ll also share some intriguing facts that might surprise you. For instance:

  • What makes fancy orange diamonds have such a vibrant color?
  • Are fancy orange diamonds similar to yellow diamonds?
  • How much do natural fancy orange diamonds usually cost?

Best Places to Buy Fancy Orange Diamonds

James Allen

Shop at James Allen

James Allen boasts an impressive assortment of fancy orange diamonds. They have a wide selection of over 140 natural orange diamonds, each accompanied by an engaging 360˚ video that allows you to explore them interactively. Furthermore, all of their orange diamonds are accompanied by GIA certificates, ensuring their authenticity and quality.

When it comes to the hues of their orange diamonds, you’ll primarily find shades that lean towards orangey yellow or brown orange. However, they don’t offer any exceptionally rare pure orange diamonds. Many of the diamonds tend to have hues that are closer to brown rather than vivid orange.


In terms of ring settings, James Allen provides a variety of options. You can choose from white gold, rose gold, yellow gold, or platinum. Additionally, they offer a complimentary lifetime warranty that covers essential services such as ring resizing, prong retipping, and rhodium plating for white gold. If it’s more convenient for you, they also provide the option to drop off your ring at select Jared stores.

RECOMMENDED: Platinum vs White Gold

Blue Nile

Shop at Blue Nile

Blue Nile offers an exceptional collection of fancy orange diamonds, making it a top choice for diamond enthusiasts. If you’re specifically searching for a fancy vivid orange diamond, you’ll have better chances of finding one here. However, compared to other retailers, they have a smaller selection of light orangy yellow diamonds. Nevertheless, you’ll definitely discover fancy vivid yellowish orange diamonds among their offerings.

One drawback of their extensive collection is that not all of their fancy orange diamonds have 360˚ videos available. By filtering the ones that do have videos, the number of options decreases from 119 to approximately 51. Among these, you’ll come across more brown orange diamonds, although some may exhibit a subtle hint of red as secondary colors.

RECOMMENDED: What Are Brown Diamonds?

Blue Nile has gained a solid reputation as a pioneering online diamond retailer, known for their quick delivery of loose diamonds and empty mountings. They constantly compete with James Allen to claim the title of the best online retailer in various aspects.

However, one aspect that could be improved upon is their warranty options for jewelry. Currently, they only provide a manufacturer’s warranty that covers regular maintenance. Any work on your orange diamond engagement ring would require an additional cost.

Leibish & Co.

Shop at Leibish & Co

If you’re in search of the most stunning naturally occurring fancy orange diamonds, look no further than Leibish & Co. They specialize in these exquisite gems, but it’s important to note that their diamonds come with a higher price tag due to their exceptional quality.

It’s understandable that focusing on the finest fancy color diamonds warrants an additional cost. While Leibish also offers colorless diamonds, it’s the colored diamonds that steal the spotlight and captivate collectors.

When it comes to fancy orange diamonds, Leibish boasts an impressive inventory with over 200 options. The majority of their collection features the highly sought-after fancy vivid orange diamond shades. You’ll find a variety of orange diamonds with secondary hues of red, brown, and fancy vivid yellow orange.


The prices of their orange diamonds reflect their remarkable quality. Additionally, they offer larger fancy vivid orange diamonds, such as the striking 4-carat fancy vivid yellow orange diamond showcased below:

I believe that the extra investment for Leibish’s phenomenal fancy orange diamonds is truly worthwhile. However, it’s worth noting that their ring settings may not be as impressive. If you desire a glamorous setting to complement your fancy vivid orange diamond, then go ahead and indulge. Otherwise, you can find more affordable settings elsewhere. Leibish allows you to purchase the loose diamond separately, and it’s important to mention that they don’t provide any type of warranty for the settings.

Brilliant Earth

Shop at Brilliant Earth

At Brilliant Earth, you won’t find any natural fancy orange diamonds – all of their orange diamonds are lab-grown. They don’t have any pure orange diamonds either. Instead, their selection leans more towards orange shades with vibrant pink secondary hues. Additionally, they also offer a good number of fancy vivid yellowish orange diamonds.

While they have limited options for deeply hued fancy orange diamonds, there is one exceptional diamond that stands out with a stunning red secondary hue. It’s important to note that all of Brilliant Earth’s lab-grown orange diamonds come with GIA certification, ensuring their quality and authenticity.


Brilliant Earth takes pride in offering some of the most exquisite and ethically created ring settings. Their engagement ring settings are meticulously crafted using recycled gold, which not only benefits the environment but also minimizes the negative impacts of mining.

For added convenience and peace of mind, you have the option to opt for their Brilliant Benefits plan. This three-year service plan covers all the necessary maintenance costs for your jewelry, ensuring that it remains in pristine condition.

How Does a Fancy Orange Diamond Get Its Orange Color?

Many fancy orange diamonds found in the diamond industry are mined from South Africa or Australia. Australia, in particular, is known for its famous Argyle pink diamonds and fancy brown diamonds. Interestingly, these diamonds with an orange hue can also be referred to as “fire diamonds” or “pumpkin diamonds” in the trade. We’ve previously written about gemstones trade names.

RECOMMENDED: Best Places to Buy Pink Diamonds Online

The color of an orange diamond is attributed to the presence of nitrogen, much like yellow diamonds. However, the arrangement of nitrogen atoms in the diamond’s structure is what sets it apart. This arrangement, known as hyper-specific, absorbs blue and yellow light, resulting in a vibrant orange color.

How Rare Are Fancy Orange Diamonds?

Now, you might be wondering, are fancy orange diamonds rare? Well, pure orange diamonds are considered one of the rarest gemstones in the world of jewelry. Their rarity can be compared to that of pink diamonds or blue diamonds. However, the most exceptionally rare diamonds would be those with a saffron or red hue.


You can create an orange diamond artificially by either making it in a lab or treating a colorless lab-grown diamond to change its color. These lab-grown orange diamonds are considered fancy diamonds and offer a great opportunity to own a highly intense orange diamond at a lower cost compared to natural ones.

Even natural orange diamonds can be treated to enhance their color. This is a common practice and doesn’t reduce their value. However, finding natural orange diamonds that haven’t been treated is incredibly rare and they tend to be very expensive, often beyond the financial means of most people.

Popular Fancy Orange Diamonds

While there are not a lot of widely known orange diamonds, a few have gained recognition.

“The Pumpkin” Orange Diamond

One such diamond is called “The Pumpkin.” This famous orange diamond was found by a farmer and weighs 5.54 carats. It was sold on October 30, 1997, just a day before Halloween. Renowned engagement ring designer Harry Winston purchased The Pumpkin for a staggering 1.3 million dollars. This diamond is classified as a pure orange cushion cut fancy vivid orange diamond.

RECOMMENDED: Cushion Cut Diamonds (Ultimate Guide)

The Pumpkin was set in a jewelry piece that included two white diamonds. It gained further fame when it was worn by the acclaimed actress Halle Berry at the 2002 Oscars. Notably, Halle Berry became the first African American to win the Best Actress award at the Oscars, and she adorned herself with The Pumpkin on that special occasion.

“The Orange” Orange Diamond

The Orange diamond holds the impressive title of being the largest orange diamond, weighing 14.82 carats. In 2013, it was auctioned off at an astounding price of 2.4 million dollars per carat, resulting in a total sale of 35.5 million dollars. This unique diamond features a pear shape and was classified as a fancy vivid orange diamond with VS1 clarity. The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) categorized it as a Type IA diamond.

What is the Price of a 1 Carat Fancy Orange Diamond?

Now, let’s explore the cost of a 1 carat fancy orange diamond. The price can vary based on factors such as tone, intensity, secondary hues, clarity, and cut quality. While the cut quality is not as crucial, it’s important to ensure that all edges are even. The highest-quality orange diamonds typically have a medium tone and greater intensity.

To give you an idea, here are a few examples of the potential prices for a 1 carat fancy orange diamond with different hues:

  • 1 Carat Fancy Vivid Yellow Orange Diamond


  • 1 Carat Fancy Intense Yellow Orange Diamond


  • 1 Carat Fancy Deep Brown Orange Diamond


  • 1 Carat Fancy Intense Orange Diamond


What is the Value of an Orange Diamond?

Finding pure orange diamonds is quite rare, but diamonds with shades of brown orange or yellowish orange are more common. Consequently, a fancy vivid yellow orange diamond is not as valuable as a pure orange diamond.

RECOMMENDED: Orange Gemstones Names

However, the prices of vividly colored diamonds have experienced a significant increase over the years. Colored diamonds have been sold at auctions for over a 300% increase in value over time. If you manage to acquire a fancy orange diamond with high saturation, intensity, and consistent color, its value is likely to rise among other fancy colored diamonds.

When it comes to investing in diamonds, diamond jewelry may not be the most ideal choice. The only diamonds worth considering for investment purposes are fancy color diamonds, as they can be resold for a profit. On the other hand, colorless diamonds tend to lose around 30% of their value once they are taken out of the store.

However, unless you have plans to sell your fancy orange diamond, its worth is primarily sentimental or as a valuable gemstone for collectors.

Leave a Reply