White Topaz vs Diamond – Which One to Propose With?

White Topaz vs Diamond – Which One to Propose With?

Are you finding it challenging to decide between a white topaz or a diamond for your engagement ring? Look no further!

This comprehensive Twirl Weddings guide will provide you with insightful answers to the most common queries regarding these two highly sought-after alternatives to diamonds including:

  • Which option is more suitable for daily use: white topaz or diamond?
  • What sets white topaz apart from diamonds?
  • Is topaz a naturally occurring gemstone or a product of human craftsmanship?

Origin – White Topaz vs Diamond

White Topaz

Topaz, a member of the silicate mineral family, embodies a captivating crystalline structure. Specifically, white topaz represents the colorless variation within the topaz mineral species. The etymology of “topaz” traces back to the Sanskrit term “tapas,” denoting the essence of fire. This connection arises from the prevalence of orange and yellow hues observed in topaz gemstones.

Notably, topaz claims the distinction of being the birthstone for the month of November. Its radiant golden shade historically evoked associations with opulence and affluence. During the Middle Ages, individuals who believed in topaz’s alleged power to attract wealth harnessed its metaphysical properties for various purposes.

Can you recall the educational encounter with the fascinating realm of igneous, sedimentary, and metamorphic rocks?

A significant portion of individuals in the United States was introduced to this geological topic during their academic years. Specifically, within the context of igneous rocks, topaz minerals exhibit the characteristic of the slowest cooling rate.

Naturally occurring topaz is widely distributed across the globe, with notable deposits found in Myanmar (Burma), the United States, Russia, and Norway. The plentiful availability and reasonable cost of this gemstone contribute to its widespread popularity in the realm of colored stone jewelry.

Shop at Brilliant Earth


There’s no denying the familiarity and allure of diamonds. Renowned as a girl’s closest companion and a highly prized gem, diamonds continue to dominate as the preferred choice for engagement ring center stones among the majority of individuals.

The remarkable formation of diamonds takes place in the depths of the Earth, where extreme heat and pressure intertwine. These extraordinary conditions facilitate the crystallization of diamond formations, albeit in a simplified explanation.

Diamonds are not confined to specific regions; their presence spans across the globe. Notably, Australia, Russia, Botswana, Canada, Brazil, China, and various African nations emerge as prominent exporters of these coveted gemstones.

Shop at Brilliant Earth

Appearance – White Topaz vs Diamond

While white sapphire rings and cubic zirconia rings share the characteristic of being colorless, akin to diamond rings, they exhibit distinct visual disparities in comparison to one another and genuine diamonds.

RECOMMENDED: White Sapphire vs Cubic Zirconia

White Topaz

The initial stages of many colored gemstones involve their genesis as colorless counterparts. During the crystal’s formation, the introduction of chemical impurities leads to the manifestation of various color variations. However, in the case of topaz, the diverse spectrum of hues primarily stems from color centers within the stone rather than mineral impurities.

Renowned for its distinctive orangey-yellow and blue varieties, topaz has garnered considerable recognition in the gemstone realm.

These gemstones also exhibit a captivating array of colors, encompassing shades like green, purple, black, pink, and red. Among them, unheated pink topaz stands out as an exceptionally rare find. Noteworthy variations and names associated with topaz include Imperial Topaz, Precious Topaz, Swiss Blue Topaz, London Blue Topaz, Precious Topaz, and Mystic Topaz.

White topaz, on the other hand, serves as a cost-effective alternative for colored gemstone jewelry, often employed as melee stones by retailers like Kay Jewelers and Jared. Brilliant Earth is a notable source where white topaz center stones can be discovered.

When it comes to white topaz, superior quality entails minimal inclusions, highlighting their heightened clarity. Stones with fewer inclusions tend to command higher prices, while those with noticeable inclusions are typically more affordable.

RECOMMENDED: Types of Diamond Inclusions

Optical Treatments

Being inherently colorless gemstones, white topaz naturally possesses a remarkable attribute that eliminates the necessity for color-enhancing treatments. Moreover, its eye-clean quality eliminates the requirement for clarity enhancements as well. In contrast, certain other topaz varieties may undergo heat treatments or coatings for aesthetic modifications.

Imitations and Synthetics

White topaz has gained recognition as an alternative to diamonds when it comes to engagement rings. At a distance, a white topaz stone can bear a resemblance to a natural diamond, but upon closer inspection, noticeable disparities become apparent.

In terms of visual characteristics, topaz lacks the radiant white light and captivating rainbow sparkle commonly associated with diamonds. As a result, it is more prevalent to find white topaz employed as smaller accent stones in engagement or wedding rings. While it may not be the preferred choice as a diamond substitute for the centerpiece, white topaz can be effectively utilized as side stones or in striking white gold drop earrings, adding a touch of drama to the ensemble.

Retailers such as Zales and Kay Jewelers  frequently incorporate white topaz as accent stones within their gemstone jewelry collections. These pieces are often set in sterling silver, and occasionally in 10K and 14K gold settings.

Although synthetic white topaz has been successfully synthesized, it is not commercially available for purchase. In contrast, natural colorless topaz, akin to amethyst jewelry, is abundant and reasonably priced.

Engagement rings and jewelry featuring white topaz are often found set in sterling silver or adorned with gold plating.

RECOMMENDED: Gold Filled vs. Gold Plated


Diamonds possess a diverse range of hues, ranging from colorless to vividly colored, and it often escapes the knowledge of numerous individuals that colored diamonds occur naturally. Rather than presuming that these diamonds are artificially dyed or fabricated, it is essential to understand that their vibrant tints arise from the infiltration of distinct mineral impurities during the crystallization process.

Both natural and lab-created diamonds exhibit inclusions, which are irregularities that manifest within the diamond during its formation. These inclusions encompass various classifications, some of which are more conspicuous to the naked eye than others.

The clarity of a diamond refers to the absence of visible inclusions when observed without any magnification. Excessive inclusions have the potential to diminish the diamond’s radiance, making it less visually appealing. To assess a diamond’s clarity, one can refer to a chart that assigns a specific grade based on the presence or absence of inclusions.

In addition to their clarity, diamonds can exhibit a subtle yellow hue due to the presence of nitrogen impurities. The intensity of this yellow tint is determined by the diamond’s color grade, which can be determined using the color grade scale provided by the GIA (Gemological Institute of America).

Optical Treatments

It is conceivable to subject diamonds to treatments aimed at augmenting their clarity and color, although encounters with such treated diamonds are relatively infrequent. These enhanced diamonds are generally priced lower than their untreated counterparts; however, it is important to note that their overall value is significantly diminished. Notably, these treatments are irreversible and have a lasting effect on the diamonds.

Imitations and Synthetics

“Synthetic Diamond,” one of the designations attributed to a diamond cultivated in a laboratory environment, continues to persist in certain spheres. Despite the persistence of the term “synthetic” in certain circles, it often instills the notion of counterfeit. Nevertheless, a laboratory-grown diamond is an authentic diamond, akin to its mined counterpart.

Laboratory-grown diamonds and naturally occurring diamonds possess distinct worth and price points, yet share identical luminosity, resilience, and endurance.

Their chemical composition and optical properties remain indistinguishable. A lab-grown diamond can be obtained at a significantly reduced cost, ranging from 40% to 80% less, in comparison to a naturally formed diamond with equivalent grading.

RECOMMENDED: Best Places to Buy Lab Grown Diamonds

Within marketplaces, it is prevalent to encounter a multitude of imitations attempting to replicate the allure of diamonds. Numerous colorless substances possess the ability to mimic the initial appearance of a diamond. However, distinguishing between genuine diamonds and their imitations proves to be a challenge for some individuals. Notable examples of commonly encountered diamond imitations encompass:

  • White quartz
  • White spinel
  • White topaz
  • White sapphire
  • Moissanite
  • White zircon
  • Cubic zirconia
  • White zircon

RECOMMENDED: Best Diamond Alternatives

Price and Value – White Topaz vs Diamond

The allure of topaz resides in its semi-precious nature, making it an accessible gemstone with an array of vibrant hues. Unlike its counterparts, white topaz, although not in high demand for imitating larger diamonds, offers a pocket-friendly alternative compared to its more colorful counterparts.

The intrinsic value of topaz predominantly lies in its chromatic splendor.

Due to its prevalence in nature, topaz gemstones generally bear an affordable price tag. For instance, a 1-carat white topaz can be acquired for a modest sum ranging from $5 to $50 per carat. Nevertheless, the cost of topaz rapidly escalates when venturing beyond the 5-carat threshold.

The cost of a white topaz may experience a slight uptick contingent upon its specific cut. Topaz gemstones typically undergo personalized cutting techniques to enhance their visual appeal and showcase their inherent hues. However, when opting for a conventional cut, the brilliant cut shapes emerge as the ideal choice.

As for the aspect of reselling and financial appraisal, a white topaz holds no significant worth.

Topaz boasts an exceptional affordability factor and doesn’t occupy a prominent position in terms of demand. White topaz jewelry with elevated worth is typically encased in precious metals or subjected to tailor-made cutting techniques.

When evaluating the overall longevity and resilience of topaz, it proves to be highly commendable. White topaz stands as an excellent option for regular use, given its impressive hardness rating of 8 on the Mohs scale. Notably, this aligns with the hardness level of a more economical diamond simulant known as cubic zirconia.

mohs hardness scale

Topaz surpasses other gemstones with an equivalent Mohs rating due to its lack of cleavage planes, resulting in enhanced durability. It’s important to note that the hardness scale solely measures scratchability and not overall resilience. Everyday accumulation of dust and dirt poses the most significant risk of scratches to gemstones.


Numerous elements contribute to the pricing of diamonds, with the utmost significance placed on the renowned 4Cs: cut, clarity, color, and carat.

As a general estimate, a superior-grade diamond characterized by exceptional clarity and absence of visible imperfections can range from $3,000 to $6,000. On average, individuals tend to allocate approximately $5,000 towards the total expenditure on engagement rings.

When it comes to the financial value of a diamond ring, it can be described as moderate at best.

It is often remarked that an engagement ring’s monetary worth depreciates by approximately one-third the moment it departs the store, assuming it remains in the possession of the buyer and is not subject to return.

When it comes to reselling engagement rings, pawn shops typically offer approximately $800 for rings that were initially priced at $2,500. Marketplaces often prove to be the optimal choice for engaging in such transactions. For those in possession of GIA or AGS certified diamonds, exploring options like Abe Mor is highly recommended.

Diamonds possess a remarkable value in terms of longevity.

With a perfect score of 10 on the Mohs hardness scale, diamonds reign as the most resistant mineral against scratches. Their unparalleled durability makes them ideal for everyday wear. Interestingly, only a diamond itself has the potential to scratch another diamond, further solidifying its superiority.

Diamonds, however, possess cleavage planes that render them susceptible to breakage upon enduring a forceful impact. Most gemstones exhibit such cleavage properties, although exceptions like obsidian jewelry defy this norm.

Final Thoughts – White Topaz vs Diamond

If you find yourself in the predicament of selecting either a white topaz engagement ring or a diamond engagement ring, my suggestion would be to opt for the latter.

Here are a few compelling reasons behind this recommendation:

1. Diamonds possess a mesmerizing radiance, reflecting both pure white light and a vibrant array of rainbow hues. In contrast, topaz lacks the enchanting sparkle that diamonds effortlessly exhibit.

2. When it comes to availability, diamond center stones are notably more abundant and easier to come by compared to their topaz counterparts.

3. Diamonds hold superior resale value and carry a greater monetary worth, making them a more sensible investment in the long run.

4. In the realm of digital accessibility, one can easily access comprehensive 360˚ videos showcasing the stunning allure of diamonds online, allowing for a closer examination of their brilliance.

5. Diamonds frequently accompany detailed grading reports, providing buyers with valuable information regarding their quality and characteristics.

Should you desire a white topaz gemstone as an accent stone in your engagement ring, it can indeed serve as a splendid choice. However, if your intention is to acquire a diamond substitute, I would highly recommend considering a moissanite engagement ring instead. This alternative presents an excellent diamond simulant while offering its own unique charm and allure.

Leave a Reply